Opinions on Religious architecture? the way santcuaries are built,to make us feel the way they do-loving,peaceful and yet just a tiny bit afraid.In which way are we manipulated by archit. to feel so emotional

9

9 Answers

Didge Doo Profile
Didge Doo answered

I can't say I'm keen on cathedrals and the like, but some of the old churches are beautiful.

I used to visit an old church occasionally during my lunch hour. Well, at 200 years old that's pretty old by Australian standards. (Anything older than that would have just been a didgeridoo played in the twilight.)

I'm not even remotely religious but that old building felt so peaceful and had so much atmosphere (in spite of the pews being scarred by the initials of generations of schoolboys who were forced to attend) that I carried some of it away with me.  I'll post a picture.

I don't think "modern" churches can do that. The buildings tend to lack character and they're used for all manner of functions and events that tend to destroy atmosphere rather than create it.

But fear? Perhaps believers who fear an eternity in Hell might find them scary but we atheists can just appreciate them for their beauty.

Virginia Lou Profile
Virginia Lou answered

Dear Eta Er,

I just watched a very interesting YouTube series on Mandelbrot sets. The suggestion there was that cathedrals are often constructed along the lines of fractal geometry, which, through iteration, can reflect the very composition of the human consciousness...thus eliciting a sense of awe. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l8Y6xpeQK-w

The example I have chosen for you is the interior of Wells Cathedral in England.

Ray  Dart Profile
Ray Dart answered

If any of you ever make it to Blighty, try to get a trip to see Ely Cathedral.

http://www.elycathedral.org/

It is beautiful in every way, but also imposing and in a very real way intimidating.

"We are the church and you are just insignificant."

Religion is often used to keep the plebs in their place.

4 People thanked the writer.
Didge Doo
Didge Doo commented
It's ginormous. And very, very impressive.
Virginia Lou
Virginia Lou commented
Yes, I agree with Dozy...when you are just plugging along in the Middle Ages, and then to come up with an edifice like that...

It would definitely tend to keep me mindful of my insignificant place!
Tom  Jackson Profile
Tom Jackson answered

I really like what Virginia Lou has mentioned in her answer: "....The suggestion there was that cathedrals are often constructed along the lines of fractal geometry, which, through iteration, can reflect the very composition of the human consciousness...thus eliciting a sense of awe."

i suspect most of us have found ourselves "moved" by the music we hear---Ode to Joy, the 1812 Overture, and the like.

It makes perfect sense to me that what we see and the perspective in which we see it will also move us.

And of course, Neil deGrasse Tyson used that is his recent TV show Cosmos, perhaps to bolster his belief that there is no God.

Perhaps the designers of the cathedrals of the past had a similar insight into human psychology.

2 People thanked the writer.
Virginia Lou
Virginia Lou commented
Dear Tom, one point that is left out...but I'm quite sure you will know what I mean...and that is, in the churches a kind of "essence" which can infuse the building because of decades/centuries of prayer?

I first noticed it in Eastern Oregon, a tiny old church built and used for who-knows-how-long by Basque sheepherder folk. The idea being, that you can have old libraries and such with all the architectural splendor, but something special happens through constant prayer?
Pepper pot Profile
Pepper pot answered

Just google freemasonry, sacred geometry and churches and cathedrals.

Most things stem first from the Monad, which is a circle without an end, usually with a centre. 

Then with two circles from that centre point you get the Vesica Pisces.

And from the vesica pisces (Mary is often depicted inside one of these), from this you get all other shapes, squares, diamonds, pentagrams, hexagrams, and the first solid manifesting shape the pyramid.


PJ Stein Profile
PJ Stein answered

I  have been in plenty of newer buildings of worship that are light, bright, and open. They are very calming and welcoming. I was also raised Catholic in NY state. Cathedrals up there are large, dark, and lean toward the gothic type of architecture. They can be imposing, to say the least. And the Catholic church likes for the congregation to feel a little guilt. 

Darik Majoren Profile
Darik Majoren answered

Regardless of my aversion to the belief systems they promote . . . I find churches to be the most beautiful pieces of architecture there is.

I take great joy in taking pictures of them so I can look at them again and again. The beautiful Catholic church my wife ad I were married in, is going to be torn down, and that saddens me on several levels.

Linilla Schmidt Profile
Linilla Schmidt answered

Proud of this Danish Lutheran church where I was a professional cantor/choir leader every Sunday for many years. http://www.tv2oj.dk/vil-du-se-min-smukke-kirke/nodager-kirke-den-gamle-klokke-ringes-stadig-med-handkraft?autoplay=1 
Sorry it's in Danish, but you can fast forward to 6:40 minutes into the film and 15:45 to see the interior. The two guides are pastors and explain about the relics they're so proud of.  
Note our ancient tower bell in action at the end.  Nødager Kirke means Nut-acre church. Pay close attention, as there will be a quiz. . . :-)

2 People thanked the writer.
Didge Doo
Didge Doo commented
That's very beautiful and quite different from anything we have in my part of the world. The art work varies from what looks like some very ancient carvings in the wall to the much more elaborate. Even the exterior is different from anything I've seen. Thanks for posting this.
Virginia Lou
Virginia Lou commented
It is very impressive, thank you...I did go to the two spots.

Answer Question

Anonymous