I'm looking for a first name that is not too girly or too guyish. It's hard to find anything that's fits the name Sarah.I want a name that's completely neural. (But I'm willing to take any suggestions you can come up with.)?

Gwen, Kyle, Nick?

Idk

Alex, Sam, Joe/Jo, Aaron/Erin, Dakota, London, Charlie, Taylor, Blake, and Jordan are some gender neutral names that I can think of right now. But honestly you can just Google "gender neutral  names" and you should find something.